Finding a picture…
Estimate $1.47m – $1.86m
6
14 Butler Avenue, Papatoetoe
21 properties · Papatoetoe, Auckland
Butler Avenue, Papatoetoe
Butler Avenue in Papatoetoe has 21 properties, valued by the council between $520,000 and $1,850,000 with a median of $1,000,000 (Papatoetoe: $840,000). Most of its homes were built in the 1950s. We estimate its homes at a median $932,000. 1 sold in the last twelve months. The highest sale in 2026 was 1/16 Butler Avenue, at $427,500.
$1.0mmedian council valuation
$932kour median estimate
1sold in the last 12 months
1950median year built
21 properties on Butler Avenue, Papatoetoe
Finding a picture…
Estimate $1.30m – $1.73m
3
13 Butler Avenue, Papatoetoe
Finding a picture…
Estimate $1.13m – $1.51m
1
4 Butler Avenue, Papatoetoe
Finding a picture…
Estimate $1.12m – $1.50m
4
10 Butler Avenue, Papatoetoe
Finding a picture…
Estimate $1.08m – $1.44m
3
7 Butler Avenue, Papatoetoe
Finding a picture…
Estimate $1.08m – $1.43m
2
9 Butler Avenue, Papatoetoe
Finding a picture…
Estimate $1.15m – $1.46m
3
11 Butler Avenue, Papatoetoe
Finding a picture…
Estimate $1.08m – $1.43m
4
12 Butler Avenue, Papatoetoe
Finding a picture…
Estimate $834k – $1.11m
4
8A Butler Avenue, Papatoetoe
Finding a picture…
Estimate $797k – $1.06m
4
1/15 Butler Avenue, Papatoetoe
Finding a picture…
Estimate $817k – $1.04m
4
6A Butler Avenue, Papatoetoe
Finding a picture…
Estimate $749k – $996k
3
8 Butler Avenue, Papatoetoe
Finding a picture…
Estimate $793k – $1.01m
4
6C Butler Avenue, Papatoetoe
Finding a picture…
Estimate $766k – $971k
3
17 Butler Avenue, Papatoetoe
Finding a picture…
Estimate $737k – $934k
4
6B Butler Avenue, Papatoetoe
Estimate $468k – $623k
2
2/16 Butler Avenue, Papatoetoe
Finding a picture…
Estimate $454k – $604k
2
3/16 Butler Avenue, Papatoetoe
Finding a picture…
Estimate $444k – $563k
2
4/16 Butler Avenue, Papatoetoe
Finding a picture…
Estimate $408k – $517k
2
1/16 Butler Avenue, Papatoetoe
Finding a picture…
No value on record
6D Butler Avenue, Papatoetoe
Finding a picture…
No value on record
5Z Butler Avenue, Papatoetoe
Highest and lowest on Butler Avenue
Highest-valued home14 Butler Avenue$1,850,000council valuation · 6 bed · 223 m² floor · 1,163 m² land
Property values on Butler Avenue
The council values Butler Avenue's 19 rated properties between $520,000 and $1,850,000. The middle half sit between about $838,000 and $1,390,000; the median is $1,000,000 and the mean $1,093,158.
| Bedrooms | Homes | Median council value | Sold, last 12 months | Median sale |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 1 | $1.45m | 0 | — |
| 2 | 5 | $580k | 1 | — |
| 3 | 5 | $1.38m | 0 | — |
| 4 | 7 | $1.0m | 0 | — |
| 5+ | 1 | $1.85m | 0 | — |
Council rating valuations: the council's figure for apportioning rates, not a market appraisal.
Butler Avenue compared with Papatoetoe
Butler Avenue's median council value is 19% above Papatoetoe's.
| Butler Avenue | Papatoetoe | Auckland | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Median council value | $1.0m | $840k | $1.07m |
| Sold in the last 12 months | 4.8% | 4.2% | 3.6% |
| Median section | 860 m² | 453 m² | 607 m² |
| Median year built | 1950 | 1970 | 1980 |
| Council value per m² of floor | $7k | $7k | $8k |
Butler Avenue house prices over time
Median sale price by year; 2026 is the year so far. A year with fewer than two sales has no bar.
Sales by year as a table
| Year | Sales | Median price | Per m² floor |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2026 | 1 | $427,500 | $6,107 |
| 2022 | 1 | $1,650,000 | $12,992 |
| 2021 | 5 | $1,200,000 | $8,955 |
| 2020 | 2 | $1,377,500 | $8,287 |
| 2019 | 2 | $797,750 | $4,638 |
| 2018 | 3 | $535,000 | $7,057 |
| 2016 | 1 | $550,000 | $7,857 |
Recent sales on Butler Avenue
- 1/16 Butler Avenue$427,50010 Jun 2026 · 2 bed · 70 m² floor
- 11 Butler Avenue$1,650,0006 Feb 2022 · 3 bed · 127 m² floor · 860 m² land
- 4 Butler Avenue$2,221,73912 Nov 2021 · 1 bed · 120 m² floor · 860 m² land
- 12 Butler Avenue$1,690,00021 Oct 2021 · 4 bed · 134 m² floor · 860 m² land
- 6B Butler Avenue$895,0006 May 2021 · 4 bed · 172 m² floor · 150 m² land
- 12 Butler Avenue$1,200,00025 Mar 2021 · 4 bed · 134 m² floor · 860 m² land
- 4/16 Butler Avenue$525,00019 Jan 2021 · 2 bed · 80 m² floor
- 14 Butler Avenue$1,510,00012 Nov 2020 · 6 bed · 223 m² floor · 1,163 m² land
- 11 Butler Avenue$1,245,00014 Oct 2020 · 3 bed · 127 m² floor · 860 m² land
- 6B Butler Avenue$785,5001 Jul 2019 · 4 bed · 172 m² floor · 150 m² land
- 6C Butler Avenue$810,00011 Feb 2019 · 4 bed · 172 m² floor · 150 m² land
- 6A Butler Avenue$873,0008 Oct 2018 · 4 bed · 174 m² floor · 195 m² land
- 1/16 Butler Avenue$535,00017 May 2018 · 2 bed · 70 m² floor
- 1/16 Butler Avenue$494,00019 Jan 2018 · 2 bed · 70 m² floor
- 1/16 Butler Avenue$550,0007 Nov 2016 · 2 bed · 70 m² floor
- 1/16 Butler Avenue$395,00012 Oct 2015 · 2 bed · 70 m² floor
- 17 Butler Avenue$645,00026 Mar 2015 · 3 bed · 130 m² floor
- 13 Butler Avenue$688,0004 Apr 2014 · 3 bed · 143 m² floor · 1,052 m² land
- 1/15 Butler Avenue$515,0009 Sept 2013 · 4 bed · 150 m² floor
- 4 Butler Avenue$610,00021 May 2013 · 1 bed · 120 m² floor · 860 m² land
The homes on Butler Avenue
Butler Avenue has 16 houses and 5 units and townhouses. Most were built in the 1950s (58%).
Building and resource consents on Butler Avenue
1building consents in the last 5 years
- 12 Butler Avenue1 Mar 2026 · Building consentRbw - lot 1: alt to existing dwg - sliding door & detention tank. Lot 2 & 3: 2 x two storey standalone dwgs, i ncluding four bedrooms, two ensuite, kitchen, open plan living, sin
More streets in Papatoetoe
- Great South Road455
- Shirley Road416
- St George Street349
- Puhinui Road337
- Hillside Road294
- Tui Road261
- Wyllie Road245
- Portage Road243
- Kimpton Road238
- Wallace Road231
- Station Road228
- Motatau Road216
Every street in Papatoetoe, and the suburb's house prices and sales.
Sales and valuations as at 11 September 2026, from council and LINZ records. Medians resting on fewer than 3 sales are not shown.