45 properties · Papatoetoe, Auckland

McCullough Avenue, Papatoetoe

McCullough Avenue in Papatoetoe has 45 properties, valued by the council between $340,000 and $1,700,000 with a median of $960,000 (Papatoetoe: $850,000). More of its homes were built in the 1950s than in any other decade. We estimate its homes at a median $897,000. 3 sold in the last twelve months, for a median $899,000. The highest sale in 2026 was 25 McCullough Avenue, at $1,117,500.

$960kmedian council valuation
$897kour median estimate
$899kmedian sale, last 12 months · 3 sales
1960median year built
AucklandPapatoetoe ×McCullough Avenue ×

45 properties on McCullough Avenue, Papatoetoe

Highest and lowest on McCullough Avenue

Highest-valued home29 McCullough Avenue$1,700,000council valuation · 3 bed · 333 m² floor · 809 m² land
Lowest-valued home15C McCullough Avenue$340,000council valuation · 128 m² land
Highest sale in 202625 McCullough Avenue$1,117,500sold 12 Jan 2026 · 4 bed · 234 m² floor · 809 m² land

Property values on McCullough Avenue

The council values McCullough Avenue's 45 rated properties between $340,000 and $1,700,000. The middle half sit between about $837,000 and $1,062,500; the median is $960,000 and the mean $902,889.

Lowest: $340k$340kLowest10%: $388k20%: $814k20%30%: $860k40%: $872k40%Median: $960k60%: $1.02m60%70%: $1.05m80%: $1.07m80%90%: $1.1mHighest: $1.7m$1.7mHighest
BedroomsHomesMedian council valueSold, last 12 monthsMedian sale
21$650k0—
318$1.02m0—
410$1.07m1—
5+4$1.06m0—

Council rating valuations: the council's figure for apportioning rates, not a market appraisal.

McCullough Avenue compared with Papatoetoe

McCullough Avenue's median council value is 13% above Papatoetoe's.

McCullough AvenuePapatoetoeAuckland
Median council value$960k$850k$1.07m
Median sale, last 12 months$899k$803k$1.0m
Sold in the last 12 months6.7%4.2%3.6%
Median section477 m²453 m²607 m²
Median year built196019701980
Council value per m² of floor$7k$7k$8k

McCullough Avenue house prices over time

Median sale price by year; 2026 is the year so far. A year with fewer than two sales has no bar.

2016: $733k (2 sales)$733k20162017: $845k (4 sales)20172018: $910k (3 sales)20182019: $934k (3 sales)20192021: $1.2m (3 sales)$1.2m20212024: $910k (4 sales)20242025: $899k (5 sales)$899k20252026: too few sales to say (1 sale, this year so far)2026
Sales by year as a table
YearSalesMedian pricePer m² floor
20261$1,117,500$4,776
20255$899,000$6,772
20244$910,000$7,055
20213$1,200,000$6,000
20193$933,500$3,764
20183$910,000$5,957
20174$845,250$5,399
20162$732,500$4,309

Recent sales on McCullough Avenue

The homes on McCullough Avenue

McCullough Avenue has 37 houses, 6 sections and 2 units and townhouses. More were built in the 1950s than in any other decade (49%).

1950s: 19 (19 homes)191950s1960s: 6 (6 homes)1960s1980s: 1 (1 home)1980s1990s: 1 (1 home)1990s2000s: 3 (3 homes)2000s2010s: 3 (3 homes)2010s2020s: 6 (6 homes)62020s

Building and resource consents on McCullough Avenue

1building consents in the last 5 years
1resource consents in the last 5 years
  • 29 McCullough Avenue1 Oct 2024 · Building consentRbw - proposed two storey detached dwg with sw tanks, 5 bedrooms, 3 ensuite, 1 toilet,1 wc, 2 lounge, 1 dining area, 1 kitchen, single gge with deck
  • 29 McCullough Avenue5 Aug 2024 · Resource consentTo establish a new dwelling on a site and the associated use of a vehicle crossing where a Vehicle Access Restriction applies- crossing located within 10 meters of an intersection

McCullough Avenue in other suburbs

More streets in Papatoetoe

Every street in Papatoetoe, and the suburb's house prices and sales.

Sales and valuations as at 11 September 2026, from council and LINZ records. Medians resting on fewer than 3 sales are not shown.